The phone records saga emanating from Victoria's hotel quarantine inquiry resulted in the resignation of secretary Chris Eccles, the Premier's department's top public servant on Monday.
The phone records of the key players on the day hotel quarantine was announced have become controversial because of a vacuum of evidence about who decided to use private guards as the hotel's security frontline.
Though the inquiry has completed its hearings, no one in government, police or emergency management has taken responsibility for the decision.
"This decision ended up employing thousands of people and costing tens of millions of dollars,” Counsel assisting the inquiry, Rachel Ellyard, said. "We ought to be able to say who is accountable for that decision."
Dozens of security guards contracted COVID-19 while working in hotel quarantine. The virus spread through the community, seeding Victoria's deadly second wave.
We recreated a timeline of what Mr Eccles and those he communicated with said and when.
The secretary of the Premier’s department, Chris Eccles, resigned on Monday.Credit:The Age
Friday, March 27.
Midday National cabinet decides to enforce mandatory quarantine for international arrivals to Australia.
1.16pm Then Victoria Police chief commissioner Graham Ashton texts Victorian Department of Premier and Cabinet secretary Chris Eccles:
1.17pm Eccles phones Ashton and speaks with him for just over two minutes (revealed today after Eccles produced his phone records).
1.19pm Text from unnamed member of the Premier's private office to deputy secretary Tim Ada, from the Department of Premier and Cabinet. "We will also need something on food and security for people in hotels, in addition to transport…Premier will stand up at 3pm so any clarity on whether we can go from tonight before then would be great."
1.22pm Ashton texts AFP Commissioner Reece Kershaw: "Mate my advise [sic] is that ADF will do passenger transfer and private security will be used."
1.30pm Kershaw responds: "Ok that's new."
1.32pm Ashton to Kershaw: "I think that’s the deal set up by our DPC [Department of Premier and Cabinet]. I understand NSW will be a different arrangement. I spoke to Mick F [NSW Police Commissioner, Mick Fuller]."
Tuesday, September 8
Eccles first statement to the inquiry in response to whether he had been involved in any communication with Victoria Police about hotel quarantine: "No, I do not recall any such communications."
Wednesday, September 16
Eccles gives second statement to the inquiry after "certain matters and documents have come to my attention". This occurs the day before Ashton was due to give evidence, and after Ashton had given his statement to the inquiry that contained the text he had sent to Eccles.
Eccles said he did not have a copy of Ashton's text on his phone and "I do not now recall what, if anything, I did in response to that text message".
"No decision was made by me nor, as far as I am aware, any other person within DPC [the Department of Premier and Cabinet], to engage private security for use in the hotel quarantine program.
"Accordingly, while I do not recall if I called Mr Ashton after receipt of his text message…If I had done so I would not have (and would not have been able to) convey any decision about the use of private security as no such decision had been made by me or anyone to whom I had spoken."
Thursday, September 17
Ashton tells the inquiry that he can't remember Eccles responding to his March 27 text: "No, I don't recall getting a response from Chris. I don't recall getting a response from him."
On his text about a "deal set up by our DPC": "That's the level of knowledge I obviously had at that point. I don't remember where I got that or who I got that from."
Monday, September 21
Eccles fronts inquiry. Cross-examination by Victoria Police lawyer Dan Star QC.
Friday, October 9
Asked if he would hand over his phone records in his daily press conference, Premier Daniel Andrews said: “If a request were made, then of course."
Monday, October 12
Eccles resigns. In his statement, he said: "Following a request by the Board of Inquiry on Saturday 10 October 2020, I requested detailed telephone records from my telecommunications carrier. These records show I called Mr Ashton at 1:17pm and that I spoke with him for just over two minutes."
Most Viewed in Politics
Source: Read Full Article